Compatibility testing
---------------------

Equipment used:
Atari 1200XL with 32-in-1 OS upgrade from Atarimax
External SIO2PC adaptor from Atarimax
Generic Athlon64 PC (VIA chipset), with on-board 16550A UART
Linux 2.6.15 kernel, compiled for x64_64

Tests done by me (B. Watson) are all done on this setup. Tests done by
other people will be done on their own Atari systems (see footnotes).

All files are from the Holmes Archive "Holmes 2/Tape Images" directory.
All tests were done with the NTSC Atari 800 rev. B OS, except where noted.

There are probably a few files that only work on a PAL Atari. Unfortunately
I haven't got one, and there's no easy way to tell, so they'll show up here
as non-working.

If either or both of the "works" columns are blank, it means nobody has
done that test yet. Now's your chance to get your name in the footnotes!

Some of these images that work with the defaults, but don't work with
the -f option, could probably be made to work with judicious use of the
-b/-s/-l options. However, you'd probably waste more time messing around
with them than you'd actually save by loading them faster :)

File:                         Works w/defaults?   Works with -f?   Notes
                              (sec)               (sec)
ACEFACEF.CAS                  Maybe (1204)                         [1] [XL]
ACEFACES.CAS                  Maybe (286)                          [2] [XL]
ADAX.CAS                      No
AIRSTR2A.CAS                  Yes (334)           Yes (229)
AIRSTR2B.CAS                  Yes (378)           Yes (258)
AMAUROTE.CAS                  Yes (1021)          Yes (697)        [XL]
Air Raid.CAS                  Yes (228)           Yes (154)        [XL]
Airwolf.CAS                   Yes (390)           Yes (268)        [XL]
Atari Cassette Enhancer.CAS   Yes (156)           Yes (103)        [XL] [b]
Atari Microrythm.CAS          Yes (488)           No
Aztec.CAS                     Yes (695)           Yes (476)
BLACK_SH.CAS                  Yes (194)           Yes (126)
Blue Max.CAS                  No                                   [XL] [8]
Boulder Duch 3.CAS            Yes (366)           Yes (247)        [XL]
Captain Cosmo.CAS             Yes (379)           Yes (253)
CasDup 2.0.CAS                Yes (93)            Yes (59)
Centipede.CAS                 Yes (223)           Yes (146)
Crystal Castle.CAS            Yes* (361)                           [XL] [6]
DOS_2000.CAS                  Yes? (58)           Yes? (44)        [9]
Death Star Battle.CAS         Yes (217)           Yes (148)
Dropzone.CAS                  Yes (804)           Yes (549)
EASY_80.CAS                   Yes (164)           Yes (115)        [XL]
FLYING_A.CAS                  Yes (140)           Yes (91)
FORBIDEN.CAS                  Yes (283)           No
Fantastic Soccer.cas          Yes (749)           No               [XL] [7]
Flying Shark.cas              Yes (597)           No               [XL] [7]
Great American Road Race.CAS  Yes (1002)          Yes (671)        [a]
Gremlins.CAS                  Yes (505)           No
JATBJACK.CAS                  Yes (369)           Yes (249)
James Bond.CAS                Yes (388)           Yes (254)
Jet boot Jack.CAS             Yes (252)           Yes (188)
Laser Hawk.CAS                (Yes)               Yes (553)
MULKEYBO.CAS                  (Yes)               Yes (121)        [XL]
M_MUS_MA.CAS                  No
Montyzuma.CAS                 Yes (378)           Yes (256)
NINJA.CAS                     Yes (977)           Yes (668)
Panther.CAS                   Yes (513)           Yes (347)
Popeye.CAS                    N/A                                  [XL] [8]
Preppie.CAS                   Yes (290)           Yes (202)        [XL]
Quasimodo.CAS                 Yes* (554)                           [XL] [c]
RYTHMIZR.CAS                  Yes (177)           Yes (121)
River Raid.CAS                Yes (214)           No               [3]
SHAP&COL.CAS                  Yes* (173)          Yes (121)        [XL] [5] [6]
SPEED4_0.CAS                  N/A                                  [4] [XL]
STEALTH.CAS                   Yes (653)           No               [XL]
Shamus.CAS                    Yes (325)           Yes (218)        [XL]
Sqoid.CAS                     Yes (182)           No
Super Cobra.CAS               Yes (221)           Yes (151)        [XL]
TURB2000.CAS                  Yes (76)            Yes (54)         [XL] [5]
Tapper.CAS                    Yes (566)           No               [XL]
The Ninja Master.CAS          No
W_KARATE.CAS                  Yes (860)           Yes (576)
Zybex 2.cas                   Yes (938)           No               [XL] [7]
Zybex.CAS                     Yes (1009)          Yes (688)        [XL]


Total files tested: 54
Corrupt images: 2
Good images (presumed): 52
Files that work w/defaults: 46 (88% of good images)
Files that work w/-f: 34       (77% of files that work w/defaults)
                               (66% of good images)

Notes:

[XL] - Tested with XL/XE rev. C OS (ppossibly not compatible with 800 OSB, but
       maybe only because I forgot to switch back to the 800 OS, and didn't
       feel like waiting for the game to load again). A lot of the XL-only
       games would work fine on an 800, except that they've got a stupid
       "Iron Turbo" title-screen that makes a direct call to the XL OS,
       causing it to crash on an 800. As far as I can tell, this title
       screen serves no purpose other than to show off how "leet" the "warez
       d00d" game cracker is... Maybe someday I'll rip out the title screens.

[1] - ACEFACEF.CAS is side 2 of the Ace of Aces cassette. Attempting to boot
      it results in a "Flip tape and try again" message. The time given is
      for loading this tape after side 1, not trying to boot it by itself.

[2] - ACEFACES.CAS is side 1 of Ace of Aces. This game has a complex load
      procedure (multiple stages). It boots to a title screen and
      plays some music until you hit Start, then it says to flip the
      tape, starts loading side 2 of the tape (re-run cassio with
      ACEFACEF.CAS)... then you have maybe 2 sec to choose the game
      type (because there's no motor control line to stop the emulated
      tape). If you take too long, the game will either crash or say
      "Rewind tape, press Play, then press Fire" (if you're lucky,
      it'll reload side 2 correctly after that). Ugh.  After the first
      few blocks of side 1, the game disables the POKEY I/O sound, so you
      can't hear the individual blocks loading... So far I haven't gotten
      the game to load successfully after a couple of hours messing with
      it, but I'm not convinced it's impossible, either.

[3] - River Raid has longer gaps between its records than most images (avg
      around 300ms; most games average between 220 and 250ms). It seems to
      need the long gaps, so it won't work with plain "-f", but it will work
      with "-f -s0" (turns off "force short gaps"; loads in 151 sec), or with
      "-f -s270" (loads in 147 sec).

[4] - Not obvious from the filename, but this is "Crypts of Polumbous". With
      the 800 OS, it completely fails to boot; with the XL OS, it boots to
      a crack screen, which loads the rest of the tape. After a few seconds,
      the game runs, but the display is corrupted, and it crashes if you
      press Start. I'm assuming that this is a corrupt image.

[5] - Atari BASIC CSAVE program (CLOAD, then RUN). These generally always work
      just fine with -f mode.

[6] - Short leader: PRWT time on first record is < 10 sec. To load this file,
      have the Atari start loading first, wait 5-10 sec, then start cassio...
      or use -d10 option to have cassio pause before sending data.

[7] - Zybex II uses non-standard block sizes: block 5 is 817 bytes, block 6
      is 27 bytes, and the rest of the image is 257 bytes/block. Also,
      Fantastic Soccer has a similar loader with a 928 byte block instead
      of 817. Both games load just fine without -f, but none of them will
      load with -f.

[8] - Image looks corrupt (missing 10 sec PRWT at start of 2nd stage).
      It wouldn't work as-is on a real Atari (might work on some emulator).
      I added the -p (pause before block #) option to attempt to work
      around this, but apparently these images have other problems, too...

[9] - Not sure WTF this is. It seems to load fine, then you get the Atari
      "SIO fart" noise again (maybe it's trying to boot a disk? Who would
      make a DOS that boots from tape?)

[a] - Great American Road Race works, but if you want to play any but the
      first route, you'll need to manually pause cassio
      at block #364, then unpause it when the game's ready to load
      the route. Alternatively, figure out where the pause needs to be and
      use the -p option. (This is because the motor control line is missing)

[b] - Atari Cassette Enhancer asks for the "load type" after booting stage 1.
      Due to the lack of motor control, you only have 8-10 sec. to answer this
      prompt. However, if you know which answer you want, you can press it any
      time before the prompt and the keystroke will be buffered. Also, this
      tape isn't written in BASIC, but it's designed to be used with BASIC.

[c] - Same problem as [8], but this one will load with -p8 option. Stupid
      "Iron Turbo" crack screens...

--
B. Watson
urchlay (at) urchlay (dot) com
Urchlay on www.atariage.com
